What are the four factors that influence obedience to an authority figure?
What are the four factors that influence obedience to an authority figure?
1. Emotional distance of the victim: the further the victim was removed from the site of the teacher, the more shocks were administered. Indeed, in Milgram's pilot study the learner did not scream out in pain. In this version of the study everybody went to 450V. In one version of the study Milgram actually created the situation where the teacher had to take the learner's hand and place it on a shock plate for the learner to actually get a shock. In this case, where the violence and pain was so close, only 35% of participants went to 450V.
2. Closeness and legitimacy of the authority: the closeness of the authority figure was very important. When the authority figure was another participant, they were obeyed much less. In addition when the authority figure gave their instructions by phone or via a tape recorder, obedience was substantially reduced.
3. Institutional authority: Milgram tried various versions of the research where instead of being at Yale, it was done in a storefront in the middle of a Connecticut town. Here obedience dropped somewhat, but was still around 50%.
4. Group influence: perhaps most frightening was the impact of group. If the participant was simply a member of the group who was recording the events, 95% went all the way to 450V. Interestingly however, as soon as one person in the group disagreed, or disobeyed, all members of the group disobeyed -- obedience was 0%. The presence of others can actually be a good thing.
Comments
Post a Comment