How, in general, do you determine whether X causes Y or Y causes X?

-

How, in general, do you determine whether X causes Y or Y causes X?



Answer: You run a cross-lagged study. You measure both variables at two (or more) points of time, using the same subjects at both times so that you now have (at least) two pairs of X & Y for every subject. If X is the cause of Y, then the correlation between X-at- time-1 and Y-at-time-2 (hereafter: X1-Y2) will be stronger than the correlation between Y-at-time-1 and X-at-time-2 (Y1-X2). On the other hand, if Y is the cause of X, then the Y1-X2 correlation will be stronger than the X1-Y2 correlation. In general, because we think that causation always happens forward in time, the cause should be measured before the effect to get the best correlation.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Examine the collapse of Han. What factors explain how this occurred? How influential in Han Dynasty on Chinese History?

-
Examine the collapse of Han. What factors explain how this occurred? How influential in Han Dynasty on Chinese History? Answer: Hsiung Nu (aka Xiongnu) was a threat to the north, Wu had to build the Great Wall to protect empire. Han empire had to give a lot of supplies to Hsiung Nu in order to keep land unharmed. The government allied with wealthy land owners. Peasants had increasing economic pressure, which fueled the Yellow Turban rebellion. Generals stopped recognizing emperor as they became more powerful. Dynasty divided into three kingdoms (Wei, Wu, and Shu). After the Han dynasty, Confucianism became irrelevant, but Daoism and Buddhism were still popular. Han empire invented earthquake devise and anesthesia.
Read more

Summarize effective communication strategies in organizational hierarchies, and review the role and relevance of the organizational grapevine

-
Summarize effective communication strategies in organizational hierarchies, and review the role and relevance of the organizational grapevine Some companies try to encourage communication through workspace design, as well as through Web-based communication channels. some executives also meet directly with employees, such as through management by walking around (MBWA) and town hall meetings, to facilitate communication across the organization. In any organization, employees rely on the grapevine, particularly during times of uncertainty. The grapevine is an unstructured and informal network founded on social relationships rather than organizational charts or job descriptions. Although early research identified several unique features of the grapevine, some of these features may be changing as the Internet plays an increasing role in grapevine communication.
Read more

Examine the age-structure diagrams of Sweden and Kenya below, and answer the following questions. Compare and contrast the two age structure diagrams in terms of two population dynamics - birth rate and death rate.

-
Examine the age-structure diagrams of Sweden and Kenya below, and answer the following questions.   Compare and contrast the two age structure diagrams in terms of two population dynamics - birth rate and death rate. Restatement: Given two age-structure diagram, Sweden and Kenya for 2000, compare and contrast the diagram in terms of population dynamics.  Age structure diagrams are basically divided into three major age categories: 1) Prereproduction (0-15 years old) 2) Reproductive (16-45 years old) 3) Postreproduction (46 years old-death) Birth Rate Sweden  1) Population has nearly equal proportions of pre-reproductive and reproductive individuals. 2) Little growth over a long period of time will produce a population with about equal numbers of people in all age groups. 3) Children not required or necessary to support parents.  4) Availability and acceptance of birth control. Kenya 1) Population had pyramid-shaped age structu...
Read more